Yeast in school practicals: living cells, purpose and handling
Yeast is made of living cells. When yeast ferments sugar, the cells produce carbon dioxide and ethanol. Looking at the yeast mixture will not tell you the species, the strain, how many cells are alive or how active they are.
Your trainer chooses the yeast, the sugar (or other substrate) and the conditions. How to grow it and which temperatures suit it depend on the yeast and the method you are given.
Which yeast you have, and how it was kept
Record the name your trainer or the supplier gives the yeast, and whether it is fresh, stored or rehydrated. The RSC yeast-fermentation activity notes that the result depends on how fresh the yeast is and on the conditions. So equal masses of two different yeasts may not give equal amounts of gas.
Do not swap in an unknown yeast or grow more yourself. Even if the yeast was sold as food, nothing in the practical mixture is for eating or drinking.
What the gas does and does not tell you
The diagram separates what the yeast does from what you see. It does not show how to grow yeast or collect gas. Seeing no gas is something to look into. It is not a count of living cells.
OpenStax's fermentation chapter explains how yeast makes carbon dioxide and ethanol. Bubbles show that a gas is being given off, which fits fermentation, but bubbling alone does not tell you which gas it is, or measure all the yeast's activity. A colour change in an indicator, a gas volume and a pressure reading are different measurements. Use the method's controls and gas tests, and write down what you actually saw before you explain it.
Putting a bung in a container does not remove the oxygen already inside. Yeast can respire using oxygen while it is there, and switch to fermentation when it runs out. So do not call a trial "anaerobic" just because it has a bung. That label needs the oxygen conditions set by your method.
When two trials are not a fair comparison
Imagine two trials with the same mass of yeast, but one batch was stored differently. If it gives gas more slowly, you cannot blame only the variable you meant to change. Record the difference and ask your trainer whether the comparison still works. Do not heat, seal or add more yeast to get the expected result.
Rockefeller University's teaching activity compares gas from different sugars using one named yeast. Yeast uses its enzymes to break down sugars, and some sugars are used more easily than others. So that result does not mean every yeast product will behave the same, or that equal masses of different sugars make a comparison fair in every way.
Keep the amounts comparable in the way your method sets out. Before comparing results, record the yeast, the sugar, the amount, the conditions and how long you watched. If the yeast or sugar changes partway, record it: the result may no longer test the variable you meant.
A final volume and a rate answer different questions. A volume is how much gas you collected. A rate is how fast it was produced over a stated time. Compare the same quantity across trials. The trial that starts fastest does not always collect the most gas by the end.
What each control checks
Your trainer may prepare a boiled yeast comparison. Boiling denatures the yeast's enzymes: their shape changes so they can no longer work, so the cells cannot ferment. That tests whether gas production needs living, active yeast. Boiling also changes the mixture in other ways, so keep the other conditions the same, and still record the result even if you expect no gas.
A trial with no yeast at all answers a different question from one with boiled yeast. Neither proves that the gas collector works or that no gas leaked. Say what each comparison is for before you use its result.
No visible gas during the observation time can have several causes: low activity, a leak, or too little gas for the method to detect. On its own it does not prove every cell is dead. The respiration guide covers the wider comparison ideas; your lesson's method sets the working conditions.
If no trial gives any gas, record that and tell your trainer, who may need to check the yeast, the conditions and the measuring setup one at a time. Do not add more yeast, warm the mixture or close the container more tightly to force a result.
Giving the gas a safe way out
The yeast keeps making gas. In a closed container, more gas in the same space means higher pressure, which can push out a bung or crack the container. The RSC activity also warns that fast fermentation can froth over. So do not tightly close a makeshift container, block a delivery tube or carry on once the collector is full.
Stop if a tube is blocked, the pressure seems to be building, the mixture overflows or a connection is loose, and ask your trainer to make it safe. Do not force out a bung or pull apart a connection that is under pressure yourself.
Before you start, your trainer checks the yeast, the sugar, how much gas the collector can hold, the connections and how to stop. You need to know what to record and which changes to report. Your trainer clears blockages, replaces yeast and makes a pressurised setup safe. Follow the briefing on protective equipment, water baths and spills, which depends on the whole setup.
When you finish
Follow your trainer's instructions for hygiene, collecting the mixture and waste, including any indicator or other chemical. Do not pour the mixture into a sink or return any used material to stock. Report any contact with your skin or eyes, or any other exposure, and wash your hands. See lab safety for how to prepare.
Sources
- https://edu.rsc.org/experiments/fermentation-of-glucose-using-yeast-14-16-years/470.article
- https://openstax.org/books/biology-2e/pages/7-5-metabolism-without-oxygen
- https://rockedu.rockefeller.edu/component/testing-substrate-specificity-yeast-fermentation/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facultative_anaerobic_organism
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denaturation_(biochemistry)
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ideal_gas_law

