O-Level Physics Heat Transfer Practical: Comparing Cooling Curves

Study guide
Chee Wei Jie
Reviewed by
Chee Wei Jie·Academic Advisor (Physics)

Compare insulation using matched warm-water cooling curves.

  • Choose controls, interpret the temperature record and handle water, vessels and probes safely.

To compare insulation, record how matched vessels of warm water cool over time. The useful comparison is between their temperature histories under controlled conditions. It tells you about heat loss from the whole arrangement, rather than measuring a material's thermal conductivity directly.

This supervised investigation uses trainer-dispensed warm water and assigned vessels, insulation and probes. It does not cover steam or exposed heating elements. Read the lab safety preparation guide and identify the spill response before water is brought to the bench.

Choose one comparison

The 2026 O-Level Physics syllabus, 6091, includes heat-transfer investigations in its practical scope on pages 31-32. The Institute of Physics cooling activity provides a related teaching example. This guide focuses on changing the assigned insulation around otherwise matched vessels.

Keep water mass, vessel material and geometry, initial temperature, lid arrangement, probe position and surroundings the same. If the question instead asks about lid use or surface colour, design that comparison explicitly. Changing several features together makes the reason for a different cooling curve unclear.

Prepare the bench and measurements

Place intact vessels on a stable, heat-resistant surface away from the edge. The trainer determines the suitable water temperature, dispensing method and handling equipment. There is no universal temperature that makes every classroom setup safe. Support probes so they cannot tip vessels; avoid contact with the vessel wall or base when measuring water temperature.

Keep logger connections and powered controls dry, with leads routed away from spills. Do not lift a warm vessel by its probe or improvise a grip with unsuitable tongs. Agree whether the readings will be taken manually or logged automatically, and how the start time will be assigned.

Record the cooling curves

  1. Check probe readings and the assigned insulation arrangement before filling. Record the room temperature and comparison conditions.
  2. Have the trainer dispense the specified water amounts. Record the initial temperature for each vessel and begin the agreed timing procedure.
  3. Record temperatures at the assigned equal intervals. Keep probe depth and any prescribed gentle mixing method consistent.
  4. Avoid moving vessels or adjusting their insulation during a run. Record a disturbance if one occurs; do not conceal it by editing the readings.
  5. Repeat the comparison under the same starting conditions where the lesson permits.

Pause for a cracked vessel, unstable probe, unexpected spill or water near an electrical connection. Tell the trainer and follow the briefed isolation and cleanup procedure. Reaching into a wet powered setup to rescue a reading is not an acceptable continuation.

Compare what the curves actually show

Plot temperature vertically against elapsed time horizontally. Compare temperatures after the same time if the starting temperatures and other conditions were matched. You can also compare temperature fall over a specified interval; a larger fall indicates faster cooling over that interval under those conditions.

For hypothetical matched starts, a fall from 50 to 44 degrees Celsius in one vessel and 50 to 47 in another over the same period indicates a smaller temperature drop in the second. It does not establish that its insulation always performs better in every geometry or temperature range.

Cooling commonly slows as the water approaches room temperature. Conduction, convection, radiation and evaporation can all contribute. Differences in lids, drafts or exposed surface area can therefore confound an insulation comparison. A whole-vessel cooling curve cannot isolate intrinsic conductivity without a different model and apparatus.

Finish the investigation

Let the vessels cool to the condition specified by the trainer before emptying or moving them. Remove probes carefully, use the assigned water destination and leave the bench and connections dry. Report damaged insulation or glass.

The thermal practical handbook connects this cooling comparison with other thermal measurements.

Sources

  1. https://isomer-user-content.by.gov.sg/334/42ee79d0-bb13-43f5-94ab-629729f88aa0/6091_y26_sy.pdf
  2. https://spark.iop.org/slower-cooling

Want supervised lab practice?

Explore practical lessons, with timings, fees, and locations on the programme page.

View O-Level Physics Practicals (Labs & Experiments)