Cambridge International AS and A Level Physics Practical 5: Planning Physics Investigations
Cambridge Physics 9702 Paper 5 planning notes on variables, workable apparatus, data collection, graph analysis, calibration, controls and risk reduction.
Planning Physics Investigations develops a connected approach to experimental planning for learners preparing for Cambridge International AS and A Level Physics 9702. A strong plan is not a generic laboratory checklist. It is a connected design in which a stated independent variable produces measurable dependent data, controls protect the comparison, a workable apparatus creates the readings, and a preselected analysis answers the question.
Scope of these planning notes
These notes organise planning into defining the problem, collecting data, analysing results and adding relevant controls and precautions. This is a teaching framework, not a verified current mark scheme. Check the current syllabus and the instructions on the actual paper for assessment format, mark allocation and required response details. The diagram below illustrates this framework; its Paper 5 Question 1 label does not establish the current assessment contract.
A usable plan identifies independent, dependent and controlled variables; explain how variables are changed, measured and kept constant; give a clear labelled apparatus arrangement; and describe how the data lead to a conclusion. The overall design must be workable in practice and measuring instruments must be fit for purpose.
A planning exercise may use an unfamiliar context. Read the information supplied, identify any assumptions still needed and explain how the proposed apparatus would produce interpretable readings. Do not assume an unfamiliar device works in an unstated way.
Turn the question into a testable relationship
Write the proposed relationship symbolically before choosing equipment. Identify the quantity deliberately changed as the independent variable and the resulting measured quantity as the dependent variable. A calculated quantity is not automatically the dependent measurement; preserve the raw observations from which it is derived.
List controlled variables that could change the comparison. Give each a physical reason and a method, not merely the word "constant". For example, maintain temperature with a water bath and thermometer, keep geometry fixed with clamps and marked positions, or use the same specimen when material properties must not change.
Choose a useful range and at least several distinct values. The range must be wide enough to expose a trend, yet remain within apparatus, model and safety limits. State how the independent variable is varied in measured steps rather than saying only "change x".
Take repeat readings at each setting when random variation is plausible. State how repeats are used to describe scatter and estimate a mean and its uncertainty where justified. Repeating measurements does not remove their underlying variation, calibration bias or slow drift; these require separate diagnosis and control.
Design a workable apparatus arrangement
Draw the arrangement as a functional diagram. Label the components that determine how variables are changed or measured, show important connections and place measuring instruments where they act. A circuit needs standard symbols and junctions. A mechanical plan needs supports, measured distances and force directions. An optical plan needs source, aperture, detector and alignment.
The written method should allow another learner to assemble and operate the design without inventing missing steps. State the initial setup, how one data row is obtained, how the next setting is produced and when readings are repeated or the apparatus is reset.
Choose instruments by quantity, range and suitable precision. Name a micrometer for small diameter, a balance for mass, an electrical meter in its correct connection, or a sensor with a stated logger role. "Use accurate equipment" is not a method.
Include zero checks and calibration where they matter. A calibration curve requires known reference inputs spanning the experimental range and recorded sensor outputs. Explain how an unknown response is converted through interpolation. A zero check alone does not establish the response scale.
Describe advanced measurement tools
An oscilloscope normally measures input voltage against time. Current can be inferred using a suitable current probe or a known shunt resistance, accounting for loading and bandwidth. State the input connection, vertical sensitivity, time base, trigger, sampling and how the trace gives the requested quantity. Observe probe and input limits. On an earth-referenced bench oscilloscope, the ground clip is normally connected to protective earth: attaching it to an arbitrary circuit node can create a short circuit. Use only an appropriate safe measurement arrangement; never disconnect protective earth.
For a light gate, identify the two events that start and stop timing. Card length divided by beam-interruption time gives average speed during that interval, approximating speed at a specified instant only when the interval and motion justify it. Acceleration needs suitable velocity estimates and the time between their representative instants, not merely an unexplained gate separation. A motion sensor can provide position-time data, but alignment, sampling rate, response time and valid range remain part of the plan.
Other sensors require the same discipline: identify the physical input, sensor output, calibration, sampling method and environmental controls. Naming a data logger without explaining the measurement chain does not make the design complete.
Plan the analysis before collecting data
Rearrange the supplied model into a graph form. For
plot y against x, then relate gradient and intercept to the required constants.
For a power relationship , restrict this logarithmic method to positive x and y. Choose fixed positive reference quantities with the same dimensions as x and y, and define , and . The model becomes , so
Use the same logarithm base on both axes, with a positive base other than one. Plot log Y against log X. The gradient is n, while the intercept determines the dimensionless A; recover a using the stated reference quantities. Changing the references changes the intercept, but not n. The logarithms have no physical units.
For , with positive a and y, choose a fixed positive reference quantity with the dimensions of y. Define and , giving
Plot ln Y against x. The gradient is k and the intercept is ln A. The product kx must be dimensionless, so k has the reciprocal dimensions of x. Recover a from A and the stated reference quantity. Zero or negative y values cannot be included in this real logarithmic transformation; investigate their cause or choose another valid analysis rather than silently discarding them.
State the raw columns, derived columns, axes, gradient or intercept expression and how that quantity answers the question. A plan that says "plot a graph" without naming axes and conclusion is unfinished.
If the question asks whether a relationship is supported, state the expected graph behavior, such as a straight line through the origin or a constant gradient within uncertainty. Avoid promising an exact origin when offsets may exist and the model does not require one.
Protect measurement quality
Span the widest feasible range, take enough values to show a trend and avoid clustering points near one setting. Use pilot readings to verify that the response is measurable and the instruments are not overloaded.
Diagnose and limit drift by monitoring a reference, controlling the environment and allowing the apparatus to reach the state required by the method. Randomising or alternating settings can reduce confounding with time but does not remove drift. Switching off between electrical readings may reduce heating, but the next reading still needs a defined settling procedure. State which change each procedure addresses.
Reduce parallax with normal viewing, improve a length endpoint with a fiducial marker and set square, time multiple cycles for periodic motion, or measure multiple repeated spacings for a wave pattern. Each detail must attach to a named measurement.
Assess risk and state precautions
Identify the hazard, possible harm and control. For a laser, use a low-power beam below eye level, terminate it and remove reflective objects. For hot equipment, use insulation, allow cooling and monitor temperature. For falling masses, use a tray or padding and keep feet clear. For high current, include current limitation and disconnect between readings.
Do not invent hazards unrelated to the proposed arrangement. A generic instruction to wear goggles does not explain a precaution without a credible eye hazard and suitable protection for it. Risk controls must preserve the measurement method while reducing likelihood or severity.
Worked application: plan a cooling investigation
This is a proposed test, not a measured result. Prepare several safe initial water temperatures in the same container and keep water mass, exposed area, sensor position and the container's initial thermal condition comparable. Use a consistent gentle mixing procedure so the probe samples representative water temperature without changing the cooling method between runs. Monitor room temperature throughout; alternating run order can expose a time trend but cannot remove it.
Log temperature at intervals short enough to resolve the early cooling curve, allowing for probe response time. Define the analysis start consistently after transfer and mixing. Estimate its initial slope from a justified local fit, report the fitting interval and uncertainty, and pair it with the temperature excess at that same start. A long-interval temperature fall divided by time is an average rate, not automatically the initial rate.
Write . For positive temperature excess, a constant-coefficient Newton cooling model predicts , with positive K. Test whether initial cooling-rate magnitude against initial excess is consistent with a line through the origin within uncertainty. Approximately uniform water temperature, stable surroundings and a comparable effective cooling coefficient are model conditions, not outcomes guaranteed by using the same container. Temperature-dependent heat transfer, evaporation and different container thermal histories may cause deviations. Repeat comparable runs and examine scatter and residuals before drawing a bounded conclusion.
Use a stable heatproof surface, suitable handling protection and a safe temperature range. Prevent hot-water spills and keep electrical connectors dry.
Common misconceptions and corrections
- Writing a memorised checklist before identifying the relationship. Let the model determine measurements and analysis.
- Calling a calculated value the only raw dependent reading. Preserve the direct observations too.
- Naming every other quantity as controlled. Select variables that can materially affect the comparison.
- Writing "keep temperature constant" without a method. Name the bath, monitor or equilibration procedure.
- Saying "change x" without range or mechanism. State measured settings and how they are produced.
- Using only two values because a line needs two points. Collect enough values to reveal scatter and trend.
- Repeating readings without saying how they are used. State mean and uncertainty treatment.
- Using repeats to correct drift. Change order or recheck a reference to diagnose time-dependent bias.
- Drawing apparatus decoratively. Show the functional geometry, connections and measuring positions.
- Omitting labels because the prose names equipment. A clear labelled diagram makes the measurement arrangement reproducible; follow the actual question for required response details.
- Writing "use a ruler" for a tiny dimension. Choose fit-for-purpose range and resolution.
- Naming a sensor without calibration. Explain reference inputs and output conversion.
- Saying "use a data logger" without a measurement chain. State sensor, sampling and calculation.
- Using a light gate without defining the interrupting length. Name the card or gate separation used.
- Using an oscilloscope without time base or vertical scale. State settings and division conversion.
- Plotting before rearranging the equation. Derive axes, gradient and intercept first.
- Taking logarithms without checking dimensions or domain. Use a positive dimensionless ratio with an explicitly stated reference quantity.
- Giving logarithms physical units. The logarithm itself is dimensionless.
- Saying only "plot a suitable graph". Name both axes and the conclusion route.
- Assuming every expected line crosses the origin. Follow the supplied model and account for offsets.
- Giving a generic safety phrase. Link hazard, harm and control to the apparatus.
- Replacing the proposed experiment as an improvement. Modify the stated investigation realistically.
- Claiming a plan proves the relationship. It defines how evidence would test it over a bounded range.
Assessment guidance
Start with the symbolic relationship, then state independent, dependent and controlled variables. Describe a broad safe range, several settings, repeats and exactly how each raw measurement is made. Draw and label the functional apparatus, including circuit connections, sensor position or measured geometry. Specify zero checks, calibration and control procedures where relevant. Rearrange the model to name graph axes, derived columns, gradient and intercept meaning before discussing results. Finish with additional measurement-quality detail and specific risk controls. Every procedural sentence should help another person collect the intended evidence without inventing a missing step.
Retrieval practice
Given one linear, one power-law and one exponential relationship, design three compact Paper 5 plans. For each, identify variables and controls, sketch a workable labelled arrangement, choose instruments and calibration, define range and repeats, list raw and derived table columns, derive graph axes and constant extraction, and state two matched risk or quality controls.
Theory and practical ownership
Theory notes explain the physical relationships supplied or recalled within their syllabus topics. This note covers a general planning framework. Practicals 1 to 4 supply measurement and apparatus patterns, while Practical 6 focuses on analysis, conclusions and uncertainty. Consult current official instructions before mapping these teaching sections onto particular examination questions.
Return to the Cambridge International AS and A Level Physics practical hub.
Official source
Cambridge International, AS and A Level Physics 9702 syllabus for examinations in 2025, 2026 and 2027, listed as the official reference to consult for current assessment requirements. Its PDF contents have not been verified in this review; the explanations above are teaching guidance rather than a confirmed current marking checklist.
Check this topic from memory
Attempt the matching topic bank before reopening the notes. Use each missed idea to decide what to review next.
Start the topic quiz
